This "award" is for the most disappointing player...the guy you expected more from (either because of past performance or anticipated growth) but you didn't get it. This is the only negative "award" on the list but it's an interesting and in some ways important conversation piece.
You can vote in the comment section below. One vote per person, make your vote easy to understand, and also favor us with a bit of explanation about your choice if you would. Voting will be open for the next couple days and then winners will be declared.