Don't miss the specific Travis Outlaw question a few posts below. After you're done with that, here's a more general follow up for you.
I'd like to see folks rate our personnel on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being "This person is critical to the future of the team and must be retained at all costs" and 1 being "It's critical we get rid of this person". All factors are in play--talent, skill set, age, chemistry, character, financial issues...the whole ball of wax. If you'd like to explain your reasoning on some of your ratings, you're welcome to do so.
To make it easy, here's the list. Feel free to copy and paste if you wish.