Blazersedge: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: RSL Soapbox for Real Salt Lake Fans!

Barbosa Trade Analysis

with the rumors coming from the arizona republic about trading barbosa for webster the #13 and someone else, is this the right deal for the blazers. Barbosa helps the PG situation but this trade would hurt the SF situation. 

Questions

1. Would it be worth giving up a starter for a sixth man?

2. Is the need at PG greater than that at SF?

3. Is a Barbosa-Outlaw combo better than Blake-Webster?

4.Can Outlaw start with his asthma?

5.Will we resign James Jones?

6. Will Barbosa be the starter?

7. Is there another combination of  players that would get this deal done?

please help anser these questions, i think they shed light on wether or not this would be a good trade.

Poll
What would you give up for Leandro Barbosa?
Martell + #13 + Player to Be Named (Proposed)
78 votes
Travis Instead of Martell
18 votes
Wouldn't Do it
114 votes
Another Combination of players, explain as a comment
16 votes

226 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 18 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

I voted wouldn't do it

because I am not convinced that he is a point guard. I think he could play SOME point but he’s not pure…

Maybe, just once, someone will call me 'Sir' without adding, 'You're making a scene.' -Homer J Simpson

by Poot on Jun 20, 2008 10:50 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

go ahead

I would do this for Martell and maybe a Mcbob (didnt check Salary)plus #13 and 55 secound rounder but would want there First round#15 and Barbi. NIce addition, the people that think we are going to get that perfect point or forward are crazy unless we give up some big time talent AND NO TROUT AND MARTELL ARE NOT BIG TIME TALENT.We will have a hard time finding a point that avg. 7-8 assist that a team will give up.07-06 season He averg.18 ppg and 4 assist. good lifetime FG and 3pt shooter.A great addition to a playoff team.

by wegotjs on Jun 20, 2008 10:50 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Link and comment

The article in question is here. Reading the article requires answering a few standard marketing questions so they can serve you ads specifically targeted to your demographic group. Just tell ‘em your 97 and see what ads appear. :)

As mentioned, the rumor the AR is reporting on is Webster + #13 + another player for Leandro Barbosa.

A couple other points worth mentioning:
  • In the article, Barbosa is interviewed and says he does not want a trade.
  • Boris Diaw is also available, FWIW
  • Barbosa has 4 years left on his contract, making $5.6 million next year. Martell has one year left at nearly $3 million; other Blazers who are close in salary (and would work in a trade) include Channing Frye, James Jones, and Brandon Roy. Obviously, they can’t have B-Roy for Barbosa. Jones cannot be included in any trade until he decides whether or not to exercise his final option (i.e. the Blazers cannot trade him, followed by him opting out—no matter how much Robert $arver would like to do this).
  • Barbosa is a BYC player, so any trade would have to happen after the draft (or involve a third team or a lot more players, so the salary gap between his current and prior salary fits in the 15% window).
  • Given that the Suns are still WAY over the cap, having Shaq’s huge contract for the next three years, coupled with Robert Sarver’s well-deserved reputation as a cheapskate—I can’t believe the Suns want the Blazers #13 pick. Usually they are SELLING draft picks, not buying. Their own pick was traded to Seattle in the Kurt Thomas deal, though I think they have Atlanta’s pick this year.

It’s a deal I’d consider, but given who the owner is, I’m sure that the deal can be made better from a basketball point of view if KP is willing to SPAM.

by EngineerScotty on Jun 20, 2008 10:54 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Another thread?

There is already a thread going on this exact same topic, with a very similar poll, just 2 spots down the fanpost list.

I’d link the author of this one to Dave’s site posting guidelines, but I’m too lazy. Suffice it to say, this post is violating one of them.

by douglast on Jun 20, 2008 11:11 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Don't know

Why Portland would want to give up a SF that has made huge strides this past season for a PG, and then keep all the other 3 mediocre PGs that they have on the team.

I also don’t know why the Suns would want to trade their back-up PG and not ask for at least another PG in return.

Going after Barbosa makes sense, but not giving up Martell in return.

by damir on Jun 20, 2008 12:09 PM PDT reply actions   1 recs

Barbosa is not a point gaurd

but…... he does like to play the up and down game, which i like. We need some one like that. That said, don’t go trading Martell, or Travis unless it’s in a packaged deal for Lebron James. Their ceilings are too high, and have both shown improvement..
BTW, Lebron James would be the perfect point gaurd. Reminds me of Magic Johnson. I think him and Broy would be like MJ and Pippen..probly never gonna happen though.

by BroyTheTruth on Jun 20, 2008 12:29 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Over Reaction

Don’t trade Outlaw or Martell unless it is for LBJ?

Look in the mirror and cut your self, because you are really bleeding the Black and Red if you believe that.

Martell and Travis are good players with potential to be more, but that is all. They are not worth the (argueably) best player in the game.

This is a very realistic trade proposal in my opinion, and if a trade goes down that includes Martell or Travis we should expect this level of talent in return, (someone like a LB).

by usmcr3049 on Jun 20, 2008 1:43 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

No way do I do this trade

Barbosa doesn’t want to leave

He is a shooting guard in a point guards body- we are covered at the SG position

Martell is hungry and is improving by leaps and bounds. Why not see where this goes with him?

I would like to see how Barbosa does under a different system than he has been playing in Phoenix. How curious am I? Maybe Sergio and #13, no more.

I'm a little confused by your tactics

by oderiferous emanations 74 on Jun 20, 2008 2:46 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Nice

I would definitely be Jack +13 curious

Life is exhausting when you are this stupid.

by jonestr on Jun 20, 2008 5:41 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

An idea

Couldn’t we use Barbossa’s speed to guard the quick PG’s who kill us (the Pargo’s and Nate Robinson’s of the world) then play Brandon at the point?

Just let them switch the 1/2 on offense/defense.

by AndrewD on Jun 20, 2008 3:12 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

that's exactly why i would do the trade

Leaving this blank 'til I think of something funny

by Zaron5551 on Jun 20, 2008 3:44 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

That's the idea

But thus far in his career, Barbosa has been an awful defender. Not just bad, awful. With his, what, 7 feet? wingspan and speed, he should be a GREAT defender. It’d be a no-brainer if he COULD defend PGs, even bad but quick ones like Earl Watson…

He’s a terrific, terrific shooter, and super quick, but doesn’t have much PG skills and is kinda like PHX’s Travis Outlaw, with all of his lack of defensive ability and BBIQ.

If we did get him, yeah, Roy would guard the 2 and Barbosa would guard the 1, and kinda switch on offense, but that might not be best on either end.

Mortimer

by Mortimer on Jun 20, 2008 4:49 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Maybe he can Eddie House it

I just verbed Eddie House as because he seems to have morphed into a defender based solely on his play during the finals(but it seems to me that he was just overplaying passing lanes which should not qualify anyone as a good defender.). It seems that Barbosa has more tools than an Eddie House and could be a really lock down defender. Maybe he just needs to be Thibodeau’d

Life is exhausting when you are this stupid.

by jonestr on Jun 20, 2008 5:46 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Make them match up against us with Roy at the point

I certainly wouldn’t make any trades to match up against Nate Robinson or Pargo. Watch them try and guard Roy. When we have a starting lineup of Roy, Webster, Prince, LA and Oden. The bigger guards can just funnel those little guy’s into our frontline. Think of the combined wingspan of those 3 plus we will have big guards.

Sure a little pip squeek might give us trouble every now and then but we will give them much much more than they can handle.

I'm a little confused by your tactics

by oderiferous emanations 74 on Jun 20, 2008 4:40 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

That seems like the defenses choice

not ours. I guess we could force the opponents hand by playing a big backcourt, but it is not necessarily a gain for us as guys like Pargo and Robinson can get back in transition quickly and potentially give us trouble.

Life is exhausting when you are this stupid.

by jonestr on Jun 20, 2008 5:49 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

copied from the other thread

defense and court vision are definitely the two knocks on barbosa. but i have bad memories of felton just killing blake/jack too. those guys aren’t defensive stalwarts. from a court vision standpoint i prefer blake to barbosa but not by much – and again i would prefer to have barbosa/blake/roy/rudy than what we have now, by leaps and bounds. that is arguably the #2 backcourt combination in the nba behind boston rondo/pierce/allen/house- tons of flexiblity, great shooting, different sizes, speeds, looks. that would just make me drool if i was nate (even if i knew barbosa was good for a few souvenir passes into the stands every game).

that backcourt is setting the terms of every game we play… we would determine the pace, we are the aggressors with that lineup. as it stands we are too reactive. adding barbosa also means less double teams on roy, etc. less minutes roy would need to play, etc. i love the added flexibility it would provide.

and yes with our size we might not need a top 10 point guard, but if barbosa is available for scraps, we would be foolish to wait… way better to have extra talent than being in a position where we are hoping that average talent will play over its head.

WITH ALL OF THAT SAID, i talked to HA about this topic this morning. here you go….

me: we would be crazy not to do this barbosa trade right?
TrueHoop: Is it real?
me: i think realer than most
not to get all french philosopher on you, but is anything real?
TrueHoop: Big difference between owners actually considering it, and Sam Smith talking about it.
me: indeed… but if they are counting on nash for 3 years then $arver has got to be thinking i dont want to pay this guy
and the phoenix fans dont seem overly enthralled with him
we’ve got cheap talent, $ and picks to help cushion the rebuild
how many games does barbosa win for them next year, 3 or 4 max?
TrueHoop: Yeah, it’s interesting.
I’m lukewarm on him as a point guard
love him as a backup 2
and pray he’s still developing
he needs to change speeds
move laterally
defend …
He’d be the end of Sergio
me: sergio’s jumper is the end of sergio i’m higher on barbosa as a point with blake backup than almost any other possible starter/backup combo, definitely than any of the others floated
as a backup 2 him rudy and travis could be a vicious combo
TrueHoop: I guess the good part is that if you start him with Roy, he spots up and shoots over people.
And he brings a lot of joy to the court
me: ideally greg covers up some of his gambling/perimeter defense problems too … and on offense with barbosa/roy/shooter/aldridge/oden that is so many matchup problems
TrueHoop: Greg’s going to average a foul a minute this season
me: lol oh i know
TrueHoop: we’re going to need more perimeter D
not less
me: indeed. do you think barbosa will be an allstar in the next 2-3 years
TrueHoop: He’s in a group of like 100 players who COULD be, but it’ll take a kind of internal drive that he has not yet demonstrated.
me: gotcha… my enthusiasm is tempered… you win this round thanks henry
TrueHoop: I trust Pritchard.
And I’m fine with giving up Martell.
but the cap space is precious.

"Honor Terry Porter." Email me with your TP stories and memories.

by Ben. on Jun 20, 2008 5:01 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Martell is only 21!!!

Martell wouldn’t even have graduated college yet. If he were in this draft I think we’d be lucky to be able to get him at 13. And Martell and Sergio are the same age, yet most fans give Sergio a pass. Some even favor James Jones over Martell even though he is completely one dimensional. Why is everyone so down on Martell that they are willing to trade for something that we do not need?

by FC5K on Jun 20, 2008 5:19 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Also

Usually the same peeps are high on Travis when he is entering his SIXTH season, and we’re hoping he breaks out even more.

Martell has done more at an earlier age and is way ahead of Travis in the skills that are vital to the starting unit. He’s only starting his 4th season. If you think both will be good like me, I getcha, but if you think Travis is better in the long run because of what has happened thus far, I guess I don’t get the reasoning. If he had shown even an INKLING of defensive ability or BBIQ, Travis could potentially be a starter one day. He hasn’t yet, so trading Webster and forcing Outlaw to start might not be the best idea.

THAT SAID, I’d be totally fine trading either one of them for a better player. It’s what you gotta do. I think Barbosa is just like Outlaw; great in a scoring role, doesn’t fit the starters because he isn’t a playmaker and is very bad at defense despite having all of the physical tools. Barbosa has talent, and what he does well he does really well (shoot), but his negatives are so negative, and are the EXACT things we need to get better at: defense and BBIQ.

If we had others to make up for Barbosa and we needed shooting, sure, let’s do it. But we don’t need scoring or shooting, we GOT that. We want someone who can hit an open jumper, ala Blake, but not for that to be their only strength. We need defense and smarts.

Barbosa/Roy/Trout/LMA/Oden sounds great, would be awesome in NBA2k8, but Roy would be the only one who can pass and get us into the offense. We need more of a PG or a SG who can do PG things, like Roy does. Barbosa is just a scorer, and Outlaw is a shooter/scorer, not a playmaker.

Mortimer

by Mortimer on Jun 20, 2008 5:30 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

A site by Blazer fans, for Blazer fans
Start posting about the Trail Blazers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Winged_vitory_small
Whither Sports
Small
What a difference a year makes. Warning: contains no Blake, Roy, McMillan insults
Trogdor_small
I think it's time to blow this 'Roy' experiment up.
Small
Ego, Selfishness, Superstars, and Perspective
Troll_stone_cropped_small
Who has the best hair in the NBA?

Recent FanPosts

Gorilla_w_boombox_small
POLL: Who would win a Blazer dunk contest?
Ep_109_starvinmarvin_small
11/24 JD - Feelin' Froggy? Then Leap!
Oden_small
Should Brandon Roy start at PG?
Imgp4868_small
Taking Back the Neighborhood...
Oden-hulk_small
Point Guard Dilemma
Small
What do you guys think of Canzano/Quick's coverage of the Blazers these days?
Dscn06250517_1_small
Let's Celebrate GREG ODEN !!!
Gertjonnys1_small
What is wrong with being a homer?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recommended FanShots

oden's interview with nba.com
Historic photo of 1st Israeli & 1st Iranian to play in NBA: Omri Casspi & Hamed Haddadi
A modest proposal: Fire Mike Rice and Antonio Harvey!
For Ann, and Travis.

Recent FanShots

Does Roy Read Blazers Edge?
Nates Thoughts After Bulls Defeat
The Most Overrated Team In The NBA - Rob Johnson
Point Guard Dilemma
trade ideas...
Good old days
Chris Hunter, formerly of the D-league as of earlier yesterday afternoon, started the second half of the Warriors win over the Portland Trailblazers and shutdown Greg Oden.
"Monta Ellis destroyed Brandon Roy"

+ New FanShot All FanShots >


Editors

Kitten_small Dave

Ben_small Ben.

Moderators

Pict1126_small -ken

Polar_bear_small jorga

Terryporter_small prezofdeath

Small usmcr3049

Jesus_icon_i_small T Darkstar

Wallpaper_small geoffm