NBAdraft.com gets it very, very wrong
Here's their "Team Needs: NW Division"
http://nbadraft.net/2008northwestteamneeds001.asp
Here's the response I sent:
"Hi guys - Thanks for all the great work you do and the excellent website. However after reading your "Team Needs: Northwest Division" article, especially concerning the Portland Trailblazers, I felt I really needed to contact you about multiple factual errors. This would be less embarrassing if the first line of the Blazers' review was not "We all know about the Trailblazers...". Everyone except the person who wrote those words, apparently. In no particular order: "Martell Webster... selected third overall a few years back..." A great source called NBADraft.net shows that Webster was selected at #6. "Darius Miles... At this point he is merely an afterthought on this team..." He's not "on this team". Your article appeared 5/28/08. Miles was released 4/14/08. "Channing Frye...an offensive game which relies mostly on put backs." I cannot quickly locate the stats today, but anyone who watched a Blazer game this year knows that Frye shoots perimeter jumpers almost exclusively, and most people including his coach complain loudly about his lack of put backs. "The Blazers don't see the PG position as a position of need." Except that every fairly legitimate trade rumor involves the Blazers getting a PG; Kevin Pritchard stated 2 weeks ago that the primary team need was "getting more athletic at the point"; and every Blazer blog is 90% talk of which PG they can acquire. I recommend choosing a writer who either watches basketball games or reads NBA news or researches his stories."
3 recs |
16 comments
Comments
Ouch!
Harsh to my favorite draft website, but you are perfectly right. At least they did say we would take BPA as KP stated and that we were looking at the 1 and 3. I am curious about their source stating that KP would look for something other than a point guard in the draft? They state in this article KP thinks Roy is the long term point?
by MGNNoah on May 28, 2008 4:44 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I remember KP saying on courtside a while back that he does think Roy is a PG
I used to play sports, then I realized you can buy trophies, now I'm good at everything, even checkers - Demetri Martin
by Zaron5551 on May 28, 2008 5:04 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Wow, so many errors!
I’d love to see his resume…
You seem a little hallucinated with these comparisons.
by MiledAnimal on May 28, 2008 4:47 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
It's nice to the team...
But it reads as if the author just looked at the roster and maybe a few articles, and then wrote the review based off of that.
Von Wafer? Darius Miles? Frye offers defense and inadequate offense? I’d argue, like you, that the one thing Frye does more than adequate is shoot jumpers. The rest is iffy. LaMarcus gets glossed over completely.
I’m glad you wrote the author, as this is just not good analysis and goes beyond just superficial—it is plain incorrect in many respects.
At least it wasn’t negative. That shows that even people who really don’t know anything about the team will look at our roster and record and know we are a team on the rise with a good reputation. Besides actually winning more in the regular season and playoffs, this is the best we can hope for in turning around the Blazers’ reputation with casual fans or non-Blazer followers. You don’t gotta pay attention to know we got something good going on.
Mortimer
by Mortimer on May 28, 2008 4:54 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Wow that monumentally sucked
They haven’t even talked to anyone. I’m sure Joel liked his review…Backing up Oden is Joel Przybilla, a big body that provides defense off the bench….then they go on to talk about RL for th rest of the paragraph
"Be wary of strong drink. It can make you shoot at tax collectors... and miss" Robert A. Heinlein
by 92wastheyear on May 28, 2008 4:55 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
this is my favorite
“Backing up Roy is Von Wafer, the once highly touted McDonald’s All American who never fulfilled expectations, and James Jones. Jones, more of a small forward than a guard, is tall and can stroke from just about anywhere”
Since when did Von back Roy up?
and James is more of a small forward… BECAUSE HE IS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Does everyone REALLY want Sergio to be the starting PG? Um… i dunno and i love how he just says they have this cool guy named Rudy coming and then talks about Freeland for a whole dang paragraph..sheesh… and apparantly Lamarcus only came into his own b/c of Oden’s injury, not because they GOT RID OF THE PREVIOUS POWER FORWARD STARTER… and duh, Miles is an afterthought only because of his bad attitude and selfish play? Really..? it isnt b/c of his knee surgery and tendinitis and LEAGUE DEEMED CAREER ENDING INJURY TO KNEE!!!!!!!!!!!!?????
Yep this was bad… comical irritating agree with Morty.. can I call you Morty?.. that at least the overall feel was positive..stating we shouldn’t have been in the lottery..etc…
Sine Labore Nihil- Nothing without work
by BlazerFan1 on May 28, 2008 9:39 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Site is dissapointing
It’s been by far the worst Draft site the last couple years.. And it’s sad cause they were my fave for so long.
Juan Dixon Owes Me $5 Dollars.
by Outlaw is Rejector on May 28, 2008 11:00 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Great post
And I loved your message to them. You should be the exclusive Blazers writer for them, I’m sure you would do 200% better.
Juan Dixon Owes Me $5 Dollars.
by Outlaw is Rejector on May 28, 2008 11:02 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Sent a message to them echoing your post.
Current team + Greg + Rudy = Blazers losing narrowly to the Spurs in the 2008-2009 Western Conference Finals. Book it.
by prezofdeath on May 29, 2008 7:37 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I read a hoops magazine article
that called JJ a “defensive specialist”
I cracked up.
"I got the goose bumps." - Rudy translated by Alamart
by ratbastird on May 29, 2008 7:49 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Cat E
the article appears to be pretty close to right on from what I can tell.
by begottenson on May 29, 2008 12:26 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
NBAdraft.net responds - very nicely
Today Aran Smith , editor at NBAdraft.com, sent me an email reply to my comments. He apologized for not properly reviewing the article – said he posted it in a hurry while attending the Orlando camp and was going without sleep. He thanked me for the corrections. He revised the article and corrected every flaw that I pointed out. Nice
by section309 on May 29, 2008 1:18 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Wow a big improvement
Only problem is, it still says that Frye is better at D than O.
by pualo on May 29, 2008 2:26 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs

by 
























