Greg Oden and the Minute Allocation to Players in Foul Trouble
I am by no means a Nate hater, rather I think he is doing a good job and is in the upper half of NBA coaches, perhaps even in the top 10.
A pet peeve of mine, however, is his treatment of Greg Oden when the big guy is in foul trouble. I have no problem with putting Joel in when Greg gets two fouls. I also had no problem tonight when Nate put Joel in after Greg's 5th foul (it was crunch time and Joel had been playing great). However, I absolutely hated Nate's taking Greg out immediately after his 3rd and 4th fouls. How is Greg supposed to get in a rhythm when he's in the game for 2 seconds? Leave him in and let him play. If he fouls out? So what! Joel can play in the 2nd half. LMA can play a few minutes at Center if need be. I just see no reason to immediately pull Greg (or any player in foul trouble) in these situations. If he fouls out, so be it, but the way he was used tonight there was no chance of him getting in a rhythm.
Am I an the majority or the minority here? Let me know. Great W for the Blazers tonight as Joel was sensational.
1 recs |
23 comments
Comments
Agreed
A guy on my 8th-grade basketball team was 6’1" and could jump out of the gym, and was every bit as hack-happy as Greg is. My coach subbed him as soon as he was in foul trouble, and sho’ nuff, as soon as he was subbed back in he was fouling again. Finally he threw up his hands and left the kid in the game, and I think he fouled out midway through the second quarter. But for the final half-dozen games of the year he didn’t foul out once.
Moral of the story? I’m not necessarily advocating that we let Greg foul out midway through the second quarter. But hell…8 minutes, 5 fouls? If we leave him in with 2 — if we leave him in with 3, even — is he really gonna play fewer than 8 minutes? I doubt it. So let the big man learn how to play with foul trouble.
by BlazersOrBust on Dec 23, 2008 11:43 PM PST reply actions 0 recs
I agree.
At the same time though, I’m getting really sick of the refs calling these little weak fouls on Oden. They don’t treat other big men the same way. They seem to think just because Oden is big that he must be fouling if he’s touching some body.
Now sure, Oden makes rookie mistakes and is often guilty of a foul, but all too often Oden isn’t even allowed to put a body on the other center when playing defense without getting called for a foul. It’s getting really tiresome.
by Bskey on Dec 23, 2008 11:48 PM PST reply actions 0 recs
Howard is getting them this year too
Just read and article where Van Gundy was complaining that Dwight Howard was getting this same treatment this year. He said that the league seems to be trying to make it more a perimeter game.
by danielfarrell on Dec 24, 2008 8:28 AM PST up reply actions 0 recs
I agree....
in my opinion the fouls called on him were legit: hip checks, pushing on the back while going up for the block, etc.
It was wierd watching Oden come in in the 4th and be out in 30 seconds…did anyone else see the look defeat in his face? It was almost as if he tried to foul out…like he had just given up trying.
Did anyone else sense that or am I just imagining things?
I didn't mean to turn you on
by dukedee on Dec 24, 2008 12:05 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
he def looked down
but wouldn’t you if you were in that situation? the fouls were weak but they were legit. he still looks a step slow out there sometimes. chasing guards on the perimeter and pushing drivers in the back are just plain stupid on his part. over the back stuff or hacking a guy’s putback is more forgivable because I like the aggressiveness, but if you’re already in foul trouble you just gotta concede the dunk sometimes. he’ll get better and the refs will prob cut him some more slack as time goes on…
The Blazers as a whole are far more like my wife than like me in the sense of their physicality on defense.
-Dave
by chrischa on Dec 24, 2008 12:12 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
the thing is that Greg need to learn how
Bad move to avoid those fouls.
Nates job is to win games and having to go with LMA @ C and playing small ball against a team as rough as the Nuggs or the Jazz is a recipe for a loss. Oden may not get in rhythm, but he still can be there if needed when Joel fouls out.
I understand that some impatient fans want to have Greg foul out to learn how to do that but what does that teach him? It teaches him bad habits so that if and when Joel goes into decline or is injured, we will have no depth behind Greg, either that or he will have 5 fouls in the 1st Q and will play tentative the rest of the game.
The season is only a 3rd of the way through and since Greg has only played in 2/3rds of those games he is even less experienced.
Dont worry he’ll get it.
"Damn the Blazers. Damn them to hell. They are working the rest of the league like a speed bag." - Bill Simmons 6/26/08
by SpyderRyder on Dec 24, 2008 12:12 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
I agree
I agree with you and jksnake99. At least two fouls a night are because Oden did something dumb and another two are probably on the refs. I’d like Oden to cut out the dumb fouls.
"There is a difference between having two guys banging down low and having two guys who can bang down low." - Blazin'
by tominhawaii on Dec 24, 2008 3:48 AM PST up reply actions 0 recs
Ditto.
Greg has that bad habit of leaning into a shooter, or swiping their arm when he should just accept he’s beat. He’ll get 2-4 fouls that way.
The other 2-3 fouls are basically a ref reputation thing right now. Greg’s in the area, and made minimal contact, so that must be a foul.
If they called Shaq as tight as they’re calling Greg right now, Shaq would still be looking for his first title. And might not have made the top 50 list.
And that’s why this won’t last forever. Sooner or later, the refs will settle down. It’s like a form of hazing from the refs right now.
by Timmay! on Dec 24, 2008 8:32 AM PST up reply actions 0 recs
I remember shaq's first year
he was fouling out of almost every game. In fact I remember the referee’s talking about adjusting to him because he was so big. I’m hoping that the same thing is going on, because although he is definately committing fouls, especially when his back is to the basket and someone is jumping at him, a lot of the others can be blamed on whistle happy refs. So I totally agree that he needs to work on keeping his arms straight up, not reaching in, and taking charges so that he can lessen the impact that the refs seem to have. He gets foul calls like sheed used to get techs though. And that rookie official just swallowed his whistle on portlands end. Unbelievable. I watched the entire game with a great deal of fear that we would lose it. Now I’m not saying there’s some conspiracy but omg! Some of those calls were unbelievable. How did Kleiza get to the line in the first quarter? And Rudy getting smeared on that trey? Greg’s gotta get more time too, because he will never get the feel of the game when he’s constantly getting taken out. He’s like some dog that is really trying to please someone but he’s always getting punished and peeing all over the floor because of it. Sorry I guess I kind of got going in a couple directions, but hopefully you can all see where I’m going.
by Tyler Durrden on Dec 24, 2008 6:59 PM PST up reply actions 0 recs
Agreed
Sure, GO might immediately pick up another foul. But if you pull him out after less than a minute on the court, you’re GUARANTEED a completely unproductive night from him. A player has to at least break a sweat to get in a rhythm. Nate could have gotten at least something out of GO tonight had he let him stay in after picking up those quick second half fouls. Pulling him was knee-jerk coaching, in my opinion.
Thankfully, Super Przy saved the day this time.
"If [Roy & Aldridge] walked around in fur coats, with a bunch of glamour & glitz, we'd have a bunch of guys wearing fur coats. But they don't. They're just good guys who want to win and know how to play the right way." --Kevin Pritchard
by hurryup09 on Dec 24, 2008 12:17 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
Natisms
Nate’s a yanker. Not a wanker, mind you, just a yanker.
I feel much the same way when he pulls a guy for an error or missed shot. It sends the wrong message. And it sets the wrong rhythm.
And while we’re here, he needs to be more conservative with timeout use in the second half.
by Blazin' on Dec 24, 2008 1:23 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
I agree
I think that you propose a better approach. I understand Nate’s decision, but I don’t think it is helping Greg’s progression. Oh, well, all this will sort out before long.
If you can't convince them, confuse them -- Harry Truman, U.S. President
by jscot on Dec 24, 2008 2:32 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
I said the same thing in the gameday thread
Greg isn’t going to do us any good on the bench. I suppose we may want him in the game at the end to try and contest some shots on D, but the guy needs to play. Even more, our team needs to make a concerted effort to get him the ball on defense. If you don’t want Nene getting 7 offensive rebounds, let him try stopping Oden. Let the other team get into foul trouble for once. If Greg is going down due to fouls, we might as well take some of our opponents down with him.
Can I buy you a fish sandwich?
by silkybrown on Dec 24, 2008 4:06 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
One thing I really liked about Greg last night
was the way he ran down the floor in the few minutes he played. I don’t know if anyone else noticed, but he tends to run fairly slow in transition. Last night, he was sprinting the full length on two different occasions, which surprised me a bit.
by hotstuffdb22 on Dec 24, 2008 7:30 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
He's getting in shape
Since he’s dropped some of the weight he seems to be moving much better, I agree.
by danielfarrell on Dec 24, 2008 8:31 AM PST up reply actions 0 recs
agreed with OP
the consensus in my section last night was, “what are they saving him for?” it’s impossible to get in rhythm like that
by DominicanAvenger on Dec 24, 2008 8:27 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
Get him out
Nate did it right. You got to sit him down till he learns to stop making stupid fouls over and over. Maybe some day it will click and he will have at least ONE good game I hope he has sure had his share of bad ones.
by Planet29 on Dec 24, 2008 8:54 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
Coach's have never let players just "foul out"
They have always tried to protect a player from doing so, not sure why, but i don’t see that changing.
Also I didn’t think Greg looked down last night on the bench, he was actually standing up in the 4th qtr and cheering on Joel, (first time i can remember him doing that).
by usmcr3049 on Dec 24, 2008 9:49 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
What's bothers me more is
Nene was being much more physical than Oden was and yet he only had one foul at the beginning of the fourth quarter. Sure, he’s probably a smarter defender than Oden is, but still.
by Eventine on Dec 24, 2008 10:29 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
I agree in a general sense with the OP....
But with Greg last night, he couldn’t go 1 minute with out fouling someone. If Nate left him in after number 4, all signs point to him picking up #5 a minute or two later. For the guys who don’t generally have trouble with fouls, I agree completely. Like when Roy got 2 early fouls the other game, he is a guy that Nate should be able to trust to play through it and not pick up his 3rd. Greg, not so much….
RUDY > MJ
by myemic23 on Dec 24, 2008 11:35 AM PST reply actions 0 recs
I think its just the opposite
Roy is a guy the Blazers need down the stretch. Greg is a guy who needs to play, and it doesn’t so much matter if he plays 8 minutes in the first half and fouls out, or 8 minutes in 1 minute chunks, finishing with 5 fouls. There is a guy at Greg’s position who is better than him right now. The Blazers should be more cautious with Roy than with Greg.
Boomshakalaka
by jksnake99 on Dec 24, 2008 11:44 AM PST up reply actions 0 recs
Greg's gotta learn...
that if he’s not in position for a clean block, he shouldn’t try to make a play on the ball. I think Greg’s had some tough calls made against him this season but I couldn’t argue with any of the calls last night. Like Dave said in the recap, when teams pick-and-roll, our guards need to start fighting through screens instead of leaving Greg out to dry on the perimeter, but at the same time Greg needs to figure out that getting beat off the dribble by a smaller, quicker player isn’t the end of the world and maybe he won’t draw so many silly blocking and pushing fouls.
by Jesus Shuttlesworth on Dec 24, 2008 12:23 PM PST reply actions 0 recs


























